1.Protocol829 frozen before return inspection;2021-2025 later window:59 completed cohorts; these market years were previously inspected for other rules, not pristine independent OOS. Buy last monthly session open, sell fourth next-month session open. Timing adaptation differs from the original close-to-close paper; no stop/target. 2. Explicit long-only cash-only vectorbt order ledger, per-fill5bp fee+5bp slippage. Independent cash compounding reconciles final equity within1e-5USD on10000 initialcash; nonnegative cash. Sample counts full entry cohorts,not partial fills. Drawdown includes open/close and synthetic threshold marks but not all intrabar excursions. 3. Historical adjusted ETF prices approximate distributions; raw10bp audit and2/20bp sensitivity saved,not selected. Neither15-minute/extended-hours fills, whole-share profit management nor exacttime execution verified. Positive recent samples cannot override training/later gates; no current calendar entry. Sources https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . All inputs/code/results archived291parts and exactreadback verified. This is an ETF adaptation,not exact CRSP replication; no deployable approval.
return-1.72
drawdown10.92
win rate57.63
sample59
average win1.26
average loss1.74
mean payoff-0.01
quarter Kelly0
fee bp5
slippage bp5
actual allocation0
QTM90800 SPY delay train: frozen turn-of-month test
1.Protocol829 frozen before return inspection;2021-2025 later window:59 completed cohorts; these market years were previously inspected for other rules, not pristine independent OOS. Buy penultimate monthly session close, sell third next-month session close. Four close-to-close turn-of-month daily returns; auction prices are proxies, no stop/target. 2. Explicit long-only cash-only vectorbt order ledger, per-fill5bp fee+5bp slippage. Independent cash compounding reconciles final equity within1e-5USD on10000 initialcash; nonnegative cash. Sample counts full entry cohorts,not partial fills. Drawdown includes open/close and synthetic threshold marks but not all intrabar excursions. 3. Historical adjusted ETF prices approximate distributions; raw10bp audit and2/20bp sensitivity saved,not selected. Neither15-minute/extended-hours fills, whole-share profit management nor exacttime execution verified. Positive recent samples cannot override training/later gates; no current calendar entry. Sources https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . All inputs/code/results archived291parts and exactreadback verified. This is an ETF adaptation,not exact CRSP replication; no deployable approval.
return-8.17
drawdown14.77
win rate47.46
sample59
average win1.25
average loss1.38
mean payoff-0.13
quarter Kelly0
fee bp5
slippage bp5
actual allocation0
QTM90800 SPY parent train: frozen turn-of-month test
1.Fresh complete quant ledger has same3operator-liquidated trades and0live/queued orders; arithmetic saved in current observation.2.Win1/3,averagewin7.93994%,averageloss5.26143%,mean-.860974%,grossPnL-1.046053USD; quarterKelly=max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)/(avgwin/avgloss)))=0.3.All exits truncated4-6week intended horizon; zero stop/target exit counts cannot estimate their future frequencies, missing arrivalquotes prevent slippage measurement. Conclusion no calibrated forward edge and no positive empirical allocation. This is repeated ledger eligibility arithmetic, not a new backtest. Source query_trades fund=quant September7 16:31UTC.
sample3
win rate33.33
average win7.94
average loss5.26
mean return-0.86
realized USD-1.05
quarter Kelly0
position cap212.75
risk cap8.51
QTA9071350 live calibration unchanged: zero empirical quarter-Kelly
1.Fresh query_trades fund=quant13:51UTC returned3closed trades only; exact arithmetic recorded observation9172. Win1/3, meanwinningreturn7.93994%, meanlosingmagnitude5.26143%, meanreturn-.860974%, grossrealized-1.046053USD. 2.All exits operator liquidations September4, not completed4-6week signals; zero recorded stop/target exits cannot estimate future hit frequency. No arrival quotes means unknown slippage. 3.QuarterKelly=max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)/(avgwin/avgloss)))=0. No forward statistically calibrated edge from N3 with truncated horizons; retain proposedsize0. Source primary internal query_trades, saved observation9172. This is ledger recalculation, not a new backtest.
sample3
win rate33.33
average win7.94
average loss5.26
mean return-0.86
realized USD-1.05
quarter Kelly0
operator exits3
stop exits0
target exits0
QTA9071350 trading decision: retain $245.69 cash; no eligible rule
Numbered premises: 1.Fresh quant ledger13:51UTC has0open/pending/closing and only3already-reviewed operator-liquidated trades; all6quant monitors occur after nextSeptember7 16:30UTCrun. NYSE primary calendar confirms holiday https://www.nyse.com/trade/hours-calendars . 2.Saved analyses709/706 retain360intraday tests, no positive at5bp/side or higher;10bp holdouts SPY-77.7773%,EEM-71.3673%,EFA-70.4248%,TLT-59.6151%, mainKelly0. TLT2bp+.852% fails training-21.009% and2026-3.937%. 3.Analysis709 carries DBC actual swing-1.14309%,DD10.07576%,N29,wins37.931%,average win2.59139%,loss1.60982%,Kelly0; positive parent monthly return is different payoff and formation passed. R2SPY training-15.0578%,holdout+1.45192% N64,stressed-10.7372% also rejected. No retest this trading run. 4.Note733 collector13:15 returns same clinical notices, partial first-link coverage; no independent prospective drift calibration. Jobs8/15/35 active, no immediate coverage obligation before16:30. Conclusion retain245.69cash, size0. Validity: required netvalidation and timing gates fail. Soundness: ledger and saved test facts support refusal; feed/selection/execution limitations do not establish universal failure of published effects. Strongest counterexample cheap TLT or monthly DBC gains cannot repair training or actual-exit mismatch. Start cash; goal repeatable netpayoff; binding constraint validated executable edge, not349.01 account shortfall. Turnover benefits execution venues; first improvised exposure incurs costs, second mismatched exits alter payoffs, third imported win rates oversize risk. Facts end at saved history; future edge unknown. Independent unseen-data net actual-exit success would change decision; headlines alone would not. Provenance of saved experiments https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~lpederse/papers/TimeSeriesMomentum.pdf ; saved provenance, not papers refetched thisrun. Gaps: no executable quote/fee validation, collector partial coverage; no new fundamental or MonteCarlo study justified for unchanged flat trading audit.
Numbered premises:1.Fresh ledger has0open/pending/closing and3previous operator-liquidated trades; fresh list_monitors has6armed,nonebefore nextSeptember7 13:50UTCrun. Exchange confirmsSeptember7holiday https://www.nyse.com/trade/hours-calendars . 2.Read saved analyses706/705:360intraday testrows,no positive at5bp/side orhigher;10bp main holdout SPY-77.7773%,EEM-71.3673%,EFA-70.4248%,TLT-59.6151%; mainKelly0. TLT2bp+.852% cannot override training-21.009% and2026-3.937%. 3.Read648:R2SPYholdout+1.45192%,N64,training-15.0578%,coststress-10.7372%; reject. Read541:DBCmatched swing-1.14309%,DD10.07576%,N29,wins37.931%,avgwin2.59139%,loss1.60982%,Kelly0; monthly+104.6964% is a different payoff and Septemberformation passed. 4.Job35fresh list next13:15UTC,10remaining,last09:15exit0; note699 retains3issuer notices but first-link output misses possible news. Research notices do not supply independently validated price edge. Conclusion no proposals,retain245.69cash. Validity: mandatory netvalidation and formation gates remain unmet. Soundness: fresh operational checks and recorded tests support current refusal; historical price proxies, sample selection and executable quote gaps limit generalization. Strongest counterexample profitable parentmonthlyDBC/cheapTLTholdout acknowledged; neither repairs actual-exit/training gates. Startcash;goalrepeatable netcashpayoff;bindingconstraintvalidation,not accountshortfall. Turnover benefits venues; first improvisedentry changes exposure, then untestedexits change payoff, then inheritedKelly would overstate size. Facts end at historical records; future edge unknown. No new backtest/fundamental study/simulation needed for unchanged trading audit. Studyprovenance https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~lpederse/papers/TimeSeriesMomentum.pdf ; these are saved-source provenance,not refetched thisrun. Independent actual-entry/exit netvalidation on uninspecteddata would change eligibility; a headline alone would not. No quant monitor resolved early or duplicate job scheduled.
quant cash245.69
proposed notional0
open0
pending0
armed monitors6
active jobs3
intraday test rows360
DBC swing return-1.14
DBC sample29
R2 training return-15.06
R2 stressed holdout-10.74
main quarter Kelly0
QTA9071230 live record calibration: three discretionary exits do not establish PEAD edge
1.Fresh fund=quant query_trades returns only IDs9,7,1, all closedSeptember4 by operator liquidation. Exact entry/exit/qty arithmetic saved observation9144: win1/3, average winning return7.93994%, average loss5.26143%, unweighted mean-.860974%, total realized gross PnL-1.046053USD. 2.Holds20.9794/43.2302/47.2386hours are shorter than intended4-6weeks. Stop-hit and target-hit counts both0 because all exit reasons are discretionary; this is not evidence exits would never hit. Arrival quotes absent, so slippage cannot be measured. 3.Empirical quarterKelly=max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)/(avgwin/avgloss)))=0; sample3 and operator truncation invalidate calibrated forward PEAD probabilities. Conclusion no live-record sizing support. Source primary internal query_trades fund=quant, retrievedSeptember7~12:32UTC, observation9144. No new backtest or statistical significance claimed.
sample3
win rate33.33
average win7.94
average loss5.26
mean return-0.86
realized USD-1.05
quarter Kelly0
operator exits3
stop exits0
target exits0
proposed notional0
QIM90708 final decision: reject intraday transfers; retain $245.69 cash before Tuesday
Start state245.69quantcash,850.99account equity; goalrepeatable executable netpayoff; bindingconstraintcostededge and exitcontrol. Premises:1.Short-gamma hedging can buy rising markets/sell falling ones; Robeco-affiliated study https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf gives historical mechanism, not currentdealerinventory.2.Our4ETF cash-onlytime-exit transfers have negative training/holdout at maincosts;TLT2bp holdout+.852% is small and training-21.009%.3.Fundschedule and15minpolling cannot be assumed to deliver a specific15:30entry/16exit. Firstorder: adverse spreads/slippage consume a few-basis-point payoff. Secondorder: repeated same-day roundtrips compoundcosts and compete for3PDTslots; restricting slots changes the portfolio but remainsnegative. Thirdorder: transferring a publishedfuturesSharpe or cherry-pickedlowcostholdout to account sizing increases exposure without demonstrated economics. Liquidity providers/brokers benefit from turnover; hedgers may rationally pay costs to reduce other risks, unlike our outrightalpha objective. Strongestcounterargument: advanced low-cost execution can exploit this effect, especiallyTLTlaterperiod. That can coexist with our rejection because instruments,costs,periods and mandates differ. No inference of a universal momentum failure; no redesign on the inspected sample. Facts end at observedreturns; futuredealerflows and optimalexecutionunknown.
quant cash245.69
account equity850.99
TLT 2bp holdout0.85
TLT 2bp training-21.01
PDT slots3
main oneway bp10
actual size0
QIM90708 Tuesday eligibility: Friday signals expired, no pre-open order or stops
1.September4rawcloses SPY770.19,EEM68.70,EFA108.35,TLT82.21;SMA200712.1529/61.74135/101.5884/86.247. Prior20sessionreturns-.3970/+4.6618/-.1842/-.6646%;context only, not new fittedfilters.2.Friday r1positive onlyEEM/TLT, but each rule closes sameday; those historicalsignals expired. Tuesdayr1requiresTuesday10ETprice,RODrequires15:30boundary; Mondayholiday creates no entry.3.Positioncap212.7475 permits0/3/1/2whole shares, respectively.20daymeandollarvolume27.975bn/1.071bn/.930bn/2.328bn shows aggregatecapacityisnotbinding atthissize; quotesandtimeexitexecutionstillunverified.4.No heldpositions, pendingorders, timehorizon or targetprogresstoreview. No stop/target manufactured for a rejected parentrule. User schedule15:40ET entryreview and17ETnextreview doesnotautomaticallyexecute15:30–16timeexit; a marketablelimit also cannotguarantee exactformation. Conclusion no preopenorders/stops,actualsize0. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; calendar https://www.nyse.com/trade/hours-calendars .
SPY close770.19
EEM close68.7
EFA close108.35
TLT close82.21
SPY whole shares0
EEM whole shares3
EFA whole shares1
TLT whole shares2
position cap212.75
fund cash245.69
Tuesday signal known0
actual size0
QIM90708 Monte Carlo sizing and 24-day runway scenarios retain zero exposure
1. At10bponeway all4main,ROD andPDT holdout variants imply quarterKelly0 from empirical winprobability/averagewin/loss. SPY main p13.778409%,avgwin.147373%,avgloss.270744%;TLT p11.363636%,avgwin.126794%,avgloss.194806%. Actualsize0.2.20000 random24-calendar-day contiguous historical windows, hypothetical25%accountallocationpertrade from850.99, yield main PnL5th/median/95th SPY[-7.2522,-4.1051,-.9631],EEM[-5.6375,-3.4835,-1.4568],EFA[-5.6374,-3.4271,-1.1810],TLT[-4.5511,-2.5483,-.2636]USD. Loss frequencies97.66/99.545/99.855/96.34%; zero349.01USD gains in sampledwindows.3.PDTSPY windows[-6.5256,-3.4467,-.8002],loss96.985%,zeroKelly. These are historical resampling frequencies, not forward probabilities; no fixed overhead, intrabar risk, accountwidecompetingdaytrades or unexpectedexecutionfailures.4.No stop/target exit odds estimated because these parentrules have time exits; assigning targethitrates would invent data. Nominalriskcap8.5099 is not a guaranteedgaplosslimit. Conclusion protectcash; no sizing to repair the monthly shortfall. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; seed90708, stats.py; separate20-session blockbootstrapmeanCI recorded.
paths20000
SPY p win13.78
SPY avg win0.15
SPY avg loss0.27
SPY median USD-4.11
SPY p05 USD-7.25
SPY p95 USD-0.96
TLT median USD-2.55
SPY loss pct97.66
sampled threshold gains0
quarter Kelly0
actual size0
QIM90708 morning direction, range and afternoon confirmation fail to rescue costs
1. Fixed r1+r12positive confirmation holdouts at10bponeway: SPY-52.912%,EEM-43.372%,EFA-44.775%,TLT-34.105%; fewer trades reduce fee drag but do not create positive expectancy. 2. Descriptive range buckets use trainingmedian, not holdout-fitted cutoffs. SPY morningrange threshold.298693%; highrange424trades mean-.233950%,lowrange280 mean-.181613%. TLT threshold.241432%; high446 mean-.150674%,low126 mean-.185114%. 3. SPY r12 coefficient injointregression+.153300,HACt2.621 while r1-.029226,t-1.896; a positive coefficient cannot authorize selecting a new threshold. Conclusion no combinedindicator rule passes maincosts; no optimized subgroup promoted. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . Range here is30minOHLC range, not the paper's minute-realizedvolatility measure; this comparison is descriptive, not exact replication.
SPY both return-52.91
EEM both return-43.37
EFA both return-44.77
TLT both return-34.1
SPY highrange N424
SPY highrange mean-0.23
SPY lowrange N280
SPY lowrange mean-0.18
TLT highrange mean-0.15
TLT lowrange mean-0.19
SPY r12 HAC t2.62
actual size0
QIM90708 predictive significance does not establish a costed edge
1. Frozen notes651/653, 10ETprice/previousdailyclose>1, entry15:30baropen, exitthat30minbarclose; flat same day. Train2016–20, holdout2021–25, recent2026throughSep4. Only full NYSE sessions, calibrated with exchange_calendars4.13.2; adjustedSIPbars https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . 2. 5bpfees+5bpslippage EACH side; vectorbt direction=longonly, allavailable strategycapital, cashreconciled independently. Return-16.151854%, closedwealthDD16.151854%, N85, wins1.176471%, mean-0.206994%, averagewin0.028136%, averageloss0.209793%. These are simulated full-capital returns, not account performance. 3. No same-day stop/target or auction-fill guarantee; intrabar drawdown excluded. Conclusion reject this costed transfer, actualsize0. Allsixcostvariants recorded; changingcosts doesnotselectawinner. Originalsources https://smallake.kr/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/SSRN-id2440866.pdf and https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf ; this is an ETF longonly transfer, not full paper replication. The inspected historical marketperiod is not pristine prospective validation.
1. Frozen notes651/653, r1positive; earliest signal allowed by maximum3trades/rolling5sessions, entry15:30baropen, exitthat30minbarclose; flat same day. Train2016–20, holdout2021–25, recent2026throughSep4. Only full NYSE sessions, calibrated with exchange_calendars4.13.2; adjustedSIPbars https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . 2. 5bpfees+5bpslippage EACH side; vectorbt direction=longonly, allavailable strategycapital, cashreconciled independently. Return-55.191299%, closedwealthDD55.191299%, N511, wins11.350294%, mean-0.156838%, averagewin0.135632%, averageloss0.194284%. These are simulated full-capital returns, not account performance. 3. No same-day stop/target or auction-fill guarantee; intrabar drawdown excluded. PDT throttle is perisolatedETF, not a combined account allocation. Conclusion reject this costed transfer, actualsize0. Allsixcostvariants recorded; changingcosts doesnotselectawinner. Originalsources https://smallake.kr/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/SSRN-id2440866.pdf and https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf ; this is an ETF longonly transfer, not full paper replication. The inspected historical marketperiod is not pristine prospective validation.
return-55.19
drawdown55.19
win rate11.35
sample511
average win0.14
average loss0.19
mean trade-0.16
annualized pct-15
quarter Kelly0
oneway bp10
cash reconcile error0
actual size0
QIM90708 TLT rod holdout: costed final-half-hour cash-only replication
1. Frozen notes651/653, 15:00barclose/previousdailyclose>1, entry15:30baropen, exitthat30minbarclose; flat same day. Train2016–20, holdout2021–25, recent2026throughSep4. Only full NYSE sessions, calibrated with exchange_calendars4.13.2; adjustedSIPbars https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . 2. 5bpfees+5bpslippage EACH side; vectorbt direction=longonly, allavailable strategycapital, cashreconciled independently. Return-60.584141%, closedwealthDD60.584141%, N605, wins11.735537%, mean-0.153636%, averagewin0.128209%, averageloss0.191110%. These are simulated full-capital returns, not account performance. 3. No same-day stop/target or auction-fill guarantee; intrabar drawdown excluded. Conclusion reject this costed transfer, actualsize0. Allsixcostvariants recorded; changingcosts doesnotselectawinner. Originalsources https://smallake.kr/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/SSRN-id2440866.pdf and https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf ; this is an ETF longonly transfer, not full paper replication. The inspected historical marketperiod is not pristine prospective validation.
1. Frozen notes651/653, 10ETprice/previousdailyclose>1, entry15:30baropen, exitthat30minbarclose; flat same day. Train2016–20, holdout2021–25, recent2026throughSep4. Only full NYSE sessions, calibrated with exchange_calendars4.13.2; adjustedSIPbars https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . 2. 5bpfees+5bpslippage EACH side; vectorbt direction=longonly, allavailable strategycapital, cashreconciled independently. Return-59.615132%, closedwealthDD59.615132%, N572, wins11.363636%, mean-0.158261%, averagewin0.126794%, averageloss0.194806%. These are simulated full-capital returns, not account performance. 3. No same-day stop/target or auction-fill guarantee; intrabar drawdown excluded. Conclusion reject this costed transfer, actualsize0. Allsixcostvariants recorded; changingcosts doesnotselectawinner. Originalsources https://smallake.kr/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/SSRN-id2440866.pdf and https://academicweb.nd.edu/~zda/intramom.pdf ; this is an ETF longonly transfer, not full paper replication. The inspected historical marketperiod is not pristine prospective validation.