1 The frozen six-event holdout1997 has barrier mean-1.61159%,95% empirical bootstrap interval[-6.34633,3.30274]%; 50,000 samples, NumPy seed2026091004. Small same-issuer observations and reused market periods limit independence; no population FDA hazard or post-Sobi probability inferred. 2 Time-only net returns compared with identical SPY windows: mean excess-4.10849 percentage points, correlation.401166,OLSbeta1.621565/intercept-5.07762% perwindow. Six observations are descriptive, not a stable factor model. No selection/refit follows these coefficients. 3 New ordinary shares17,647,059 versus94,084,210 prior total yields18.75666% share-count increase; existing ownership falls15.79420% after111,731,269 total. EUR2.4m issuance costs/30m gross=8%; net27.6m. Rates and totals are different concepts. 4 Live Catalyst ledger has3losses,2operator-censored exits; no observed mean winner. Therefore quarterKelly clipped0 under tested payoff and undefined for newfundingregime. Strong countercase financing changes the distribution; requires independent observations, not treating narrative as measured edge. Sources https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars?symbols=IPHA,SPY&timeframe=1Day&feed=sip&adjustment=all ; https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1598599/000162828026057935/exhibit993.htm ; runway:query_trades?fund=catalyst .
sample6
barrier_mean_pct-1.61
CI_low-6.35
CI_high3.3
time_excess_pp-4.11
correlation0.4
beta1.62
share_increase_pct18.76
ownership_loss_pct15.79
issuance_cost_pct8
quarter_Kelly0
Two distinct data issues: historical close convention and late-2025 range/volume conflicts
P1 Fixed monthly mix earns39.6058% over2020–25 (5.7224%annualized), but72monthly observations have mean0.4861% and circular3monthblock95%CI[-0.0238,0.9909]%. P2 Regression on same-universe passive monthly returns gives beta0.4087, intercept0.1220%/month, HAC3SE0.1428%, t0.854. Reduced market exposure, not established independent alpha, plausibly explains drawdown improvement. This is not a full factor regression. P3 The mandatory swing adaptation's1239 trades have mean-0.14538%; IID95%CI[-0.22257,-0.06877]% becomes[-0.35574,0.07246]% when resampling72whole entry-month clusters. Related ETFs do not create1239independent trials. P4 Last63daily EWY/EWT correlation0.8139, EWY/SMH0.8858, EWT/SMH0.8915. Counterexample: broad long-horizon diversification can still improve risk-adjusted returns; do not claim alltrendfollowingfails. Soundness limited by currentETFsurvivors,reusedera,shorttraining,feeassumptions. Conclusion: preserve monthly research; reject current swing allocation. Sources https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars?feed=sip&adjustment=all ; AQR methodology https://www.aqr.com/-/media/AQR/Documents/Insights/Journal-Article/AQR-JPM-Fall-2017.pdf .
Premises1 AVAV fixed20/10 costed holdout1815 N6 wins2 mean12.262667%,avgwin60.104538%,avgloss11.658268%; bootstrap10000 samplemeans seed910 CI[-13.556222,44.997251]%.2 FRO frozen1784/456 N41 wins17 mean.530247%,CI[-.874362,1.958541]% remains unchanged; no new independent FROtrial. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .3 Own ledger https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev has2operator-liquidation winners/no measuredloss; exits are censored by operator and cannot calibrate stop-target success. Conclusion approvedsize0. Positive means strongest counterargument, but intervals spanzero and samples fail regime robustness. IIDbootstrap understates dependence and selection risk; not a market probability forecast. Need prospectively frozen strategy returns and larger comparable independent samples, not repeated reads.
AVAV_sample6
AVAV_mean_pct12.26
AVAV_ci_low-13.56
AVAV_ci_high45
FRO_sample41
FRO_ci_low-0.87
FRO_ci_high1.96
own_winners2
own_losers0
approved_usd0
Midnight payoff audit: no positive sizing estimate
Numbered premises:1 queried ledger and NumPy calculation18633 show three losses, mean-16.380601%, no average winner, two operator liquidations; not an unbiased strategy sample.2 reused AVO1270/1158 chronological costed holdoutN6 p.5,W1.318443%,L3.743633%,expectancy-1.212595%,return-7.331815%,DD9.371961%; quarterKelly recomputed max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)*L/W))=0.3 frozen LOVE1789 N10 stress-2.341352% and CHWY N6-1.719988% remain separate from LOVE prospectiveN1+1.211948%. Conclusion size0. Valid under required edge gate; soundness limited small selected samples, censoring and historical execution proxies. Counterexample: future independent sample may validate a different rule, but cannot rescue current p/W/L. Source runway:query_trades?fund=catalyst and https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . No new historical backtest or fit claimed.
sample3
win rate0
mean_return-16.38
AVO_holdout_N6
AVO_p0.5
AVO_W1.32
AVO_L3.74
AVO_expectancy-1.21
quarter_Kelly0
QTR9092100 frozen holdout and realized ledger retain zero Kelly
P1 Original backtest1642 reread, not rerun: 2021–25 holdout252 after2016–20train, cashmean-.094356461%,p45.634920635%,W.490801991%,L.585547862%,return-21.631824%,DD25.206217%;stress-52.657075%. P2 Own three operator-liquidated trades recomputed p1/3,W7.939941%,L5.261432%,mean-.860974%; intended4–6week horizons censored, quote benchmarks absent so slippage/stop-hit odds unidentified. P3 max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)*L/W))=0 for both. Counterexample2026extensionN28+2.31% exists but stress-3.26% and cannot replace holdout. Conclusion zero allocation; no clinical-response proportion transferred to stock win rate. Observation18615; source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars and query_trades fund=quant.
Reuse1677/1777; no fit. LOVEcoststressN10p.2,W10.702374%,L2.753813%,compound-2.341352%,DD12.985803%,mean-.0625755%,95%meanCI[-3.319283,4.058455]%,quarterKelly0. CHWY N6p.5 W4.523391%L4.828695%,compound-1.719988%,DD14.258614%,negativeKellyclipped0. PremiseN1prospectiveLOVE+1.211948%stress is insufficient independent evidence; no pooledrecalibration. Own3closed0wins includes2operatorliquidations and hasundefinedaveragewinner. Conclusion no quantifiedpositiveexecutableedge,allocation0. Counterexample largerpredeclaredcostedindependentholdout could support risk; smallselectedsamplesdo notproveuniversalnegativeedge. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars; runway:query_trades?fund=catalyst; existing recordedCLI1688andvectorbt1677 remainrejected, no retest needed forstanddown.
LOVE_N10
LOVE_p0.2
LOVE_W10.7
LOVE_L2.75
LOVE_return-2.34
LOVE_DD12.99
CHWY_N6
CHWY_return-1.72
quarterKelly0
allocation0
After-close frozen edge audit: no additional independent sample
StatisticalrejectSupply chainFRO2026-09-09 21:04
Numbered premises:1 Saved costed backtest456/analysis1764 N41 wins17 avgwin5.46270406% avgloss2.96357664% from https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .2 Python recomputation mean .530247064878%, raw quarterKelly .024266693704; saved meanCI[-.874362,1.958541]% crosses0.3 Supply ledger https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev has two operator-liquidation winners and no observed loser; cannot estimate own average loss or comparable stop/target execution edge. Conclusion approved size0. Valid under existing uncertainty gate; positive point mean is counterargument, not independent proof. Selection/regime and small-sample risk limit soundness. Repeated reads are not41 more observations. Preserve prior technical1702/indicators1631/simulation1630/backtest456; no new fit, backtest, quote or MonteCarlo in trading run. Existing costed holdout remains basis for rejection; no need to refit after unchanged issuer source.
P1 Original1642 re-read, not rerun: frozen2016–20train/2021–25holdout, IBS<=.2 nextopen1ADRstop/1.5ADRtargetorclose,fee1bp+slip5bpsside,vectorbt cashcurvereconciled. Holdout252,-21.631824%,DD25.206217%,p45.634921%,cashW.490801991%,L.585547862%,mean-.094356461%; stress-52.657075%. P2 2026extensionN28+2.31%base/-3.26%stress cannot replace holdout. P3 query_trades threeoperatorliquidations p1/3,W7.93994%,L5.26143%,mean-.860974%; censored4–6weektheses, no slippagebenchmarks. Both clippedquarterKelly=max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)*L/W))=0. Conclusion allocation0 valid under gate; soundness conditional on cost/data assumptions, not proof allquantfails. Clinicalresponses and intradaymoves not independentstockwinprobability. Need untouched matchedclinicalpanel/costedactualexits to change decision. Obs18550/18558; source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars and query_trades fund=quant.
return-21.63
drawdown25.21
win rate45.63
sample252
avg win pct0.49
avg loss pct0.59
own N3
own win rate33.33
quarter Kelly0
allocation USD0
Lunch edge gate: frozen holdouts and realized ledger support zero sizing
1. Saved1725/backtest456 provides41 holdout trades,17wins,meanwin5.46270406%,meanloss2.96357664%,costedreturn20.24256512%,drawdown24.4194659% https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .2. Python recomputes expectancy.530247064878%,rawquarterKelly2.42666937%; savedmeanCI[-.874362,1.958541]% crosseszero. Same historical sample; not41newtrades.3. query_trades fund=supply two closed operator-liquidation winners only https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev ; no empirical average loss or planned-exit success estimate.4. Census roundedtransport figures imply19.497431bnq/q and44.008370bny/y gains; BLStransport/allprivatecomp premium6.333973% is cross-sectional, notinflation https://www.census.gov/services/qss/qss-current.pdf https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ecec.t04.htm .Conclusion allocation0. Truepositiveedge possible, but new macro print adds no independent return sample. Prior technical1702/indicators1631/simulation1630 retained as historical, not current recalculation. No fresh regression,MonteCarlo or backtest warranted for unchanged rejected rule on tradingrun.
sample41
win rate41.46
return20.24
drawdown24.42
mean_win_pct5.46
mean_loss_pct2.96
mean_pct0.53
CI_low_pct-0.87
CI_high_pct1.96
raw_quarter_Kelly0.02
approved_usd0
QTR9091350 recorded holdout and actual trade audit retain zero sizing
Premises:1 Positive independently validated cash expectancy required.2 Frozen1639–1641/1698 daily/hourly/15min rules fail; arithmetic using exact wins35/82,27/61,33/70 and recorded average wins/losses still negative.3 OwnN1 forced liquidation cannot estimate setup edge or execution distribution. Conclusion allocation0. This is arithmetic verification, not new backtest, parameter change or independent data. Already-recorded costed vectorbt holdouts BTC-43.5409%,ETH-32.9637%,SOL-18.7330%; pullback family separately only1–5 OOS trades and rejected. Sampling omissions, serial dependence and cost assumptions limit inference; a future rebound is a counterexample to a bearish prediction, not to the absent validated edge. Existing simulation1652 remains sensitivity only. https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/crypto-bars ; https://docs.alpaca.markets/us/docs/crypto-fees .
Premises:1. Query readback1697/1702 retains frozenbacktest456 2022–24training/2025–Sep4holdout, fixed next-open20-closebreakout/1ADRstop/2ADRtarget/5sessions with costs; prior CLI audited as mismatched execution proxy. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .2. Python arithmetic18511 reproduces17/41wins and .530247%mean,rawquarterKelly2.426669%; confidence interval[-.874362,1.958541]% remains unresolved.3. query_trades supply returned only2 closed operator-liquidation winners; no empirical average loss or planned-exit validation https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev .Conclusion approved size0. Positive true expectancy is possible but not established; same two wins do not add an independent sample. Reuse simulation1630/technical1702 limitations without fresh paths: daily bars and fixed-payoff Monte Carlo do not prove15-minute execution. No new backtest, parameter sweep or claimed current price. Requires independent prospective costed evidence to change gate.