REV9110400 mechanism: why the institutional reversal premium may not transfer
Strategies reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:11
Question tree2171, frozen experiments2174/2177. Start state: Quant $187.22 cash, account $850.99, no open/pending lots verified. Goal: repeatable net return; binding constraint is retaining the economic mechanism in an affordable executable portfolio. Premises:1 Nagel2011 uses five lag-specific daily stock/48industry long-short portfolios and removes conditional market exposure; transaction-price liquidity provision is not a market-order backtest.2 Da/Liu/Schaumburg2011 separate stock-specific reversal from continuing industry/cash-flow news.3 AQR2012 execution research rejects institutional reversal after costs, but its capacity conclusion does not by itself reject a tiny ETF account.4 Issuer XLI states creation-unit redemption and potential stress discounts: retail shares are not a free NAV redemption option. Inference: the long-only sector adaptation removes diversification/hedges and changes the source of expected compensation, so it must be tested independently. Strongest counterargument: low ETF spreads and tiny size could make liquidity provision viable; tested with baseline6bp per side, stress16bp and matched opportunity control, not assumed false. Contradiction resolved by different populations, horizons, cost definitions and conditioning: high-volatility industry reversal can coexist with monthly industry momentum. No additional source was changing this implementation distinction; remaining gaps are point-in-time stock-level residual data, executable historical quotes and 15-minute exits. Prior was uncertain sign; net stress failure and nonpositive matched selection now support rejecting this adaptation, not all reversal. Sources: https://www.nber.org/papers/w17653 ; https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/staff_reports/sr513.pdf ; https://www.aqr.com/Insights/Research/Working-Paper/Trading-Costs-of-Asset-Pricing-Anomalies ; https://www.ssga.com/us/en/intermediary/etfs/state-street-industrial-select-sector-spdr-etf-xli . Source observations24103–24107, vintage correction24137.
More fund cash 187.22
account equity 850.99
published industries 48
test sectors 9
frozen cells 20
baseline bp per side 6
stress bp per side 16
orders 0
REV9110400 stressregime5_15_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. PriorSPY20dayrealizedvol>20% gate, notVIX. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-1.202347268207001,0.9499598378533135]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":19,"stop":17,"gap_stop":3,"target":2}; partials 3, same-dayfinalexits 3. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -7.29
drawdown 22.12
win rate 43.9
sample 41
CAGR pct -1.33
mean trade pct -0.13
avg win pct 3.07
avg loss pct 2.63
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -1.2
CI upper pct 0.95
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 stressregime5_15_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. PriorSPY20dayrealizedvol>20% gate, notVIX. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.7943843415420596,0.8182585213220581]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"stop":19,"time":23,"target":1}; partials 2, same-dayfinalexits 7. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -3.55
drawdown 31.13
win rate 48.84
sample 43
CAGR pct -0.72
mean trade pct -0.01
avg win pct 3.03
avg loss pct 2.9
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.79
CI upper pct 0.82
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 stressregime5_5_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. PriorSPY20dayrealizedvol>20% gate, notVIX. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-1.034219621696518,1.1220167616599663]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":19,"stop":17,"gap_stop":3,"target":2}; partials 3, same-dayfinalexits 3. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -1.26
drawdown 19.26
win rate 48.78
sample 41
CAGR pct -0.22
mean trade pct 0.03
avg win pct 2.95
avg loss pct 2.76
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -1.03
CI upper pct 1.12
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 stressregime5_5_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. PriorSPY20dayrealizedvol>20% gate, notVIX. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.6414368975212927,0.987275693369416]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_stop":2,"time":23,"stop":17,"target":1}; partials 3, same-dayfinalexits 5. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 3.14
drawdown 29.21
win rate 48.84
sample 43
CAGR pct 0.62
mean trade pct 0.15
avg win pct 3.26
avg loss pct 2.81
halfKelly plugin 0.02
CI lower pct -0.64
CI upper pct 0.99
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 neighbor10_15_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 10-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.31033285590242954,0.26975274239519337]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_target":1,"stop":107,"time":133,"target":4,"gap_stop":13}; partials 35, same-dayfinalexits 23. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -14.35
drawdown 53.04
win rate 44.19
sample 258
CAGR pct -2.7
mean trade pct -0.03
avg win pct 2.29
avg loss pct 1.86
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.31
CI upper pct 0.27
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 neighbor10_15_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 10-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.3248899491009365,0.09155388045638681]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":113,"gap_stop":7,"stop":98,"gap_target":2,"target":1}; partials 18, same-dayfinalexits 33. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -27.82
drawdown 51.52
win rate 43.89
sample 221
CAGR pct -6.32
mean trade pct -0.12
avg win pct 1.85
avg loss pct 1.66
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.32
CI upper pct 0.09
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 neighbor10_5_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 10-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.11811449501287959,0.5023963910054401]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_target":2,"stop":95,"time":142,"gap_stop":15,"target":4}; partials 41, same-dayfinalexits 23. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 48.3
drawdown 46.28
win rate 48.45
sample 258
CAGR pct 7.2
mean trade pct 0.19
avg win pct 2.31
avg loss pct 1.81
halfKelly plugin 0.04
CI lower pct -0.12
CI upper pct 0.5
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 neighbor10_5_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 10-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.08560103192469003,0.33188233049926]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":123,"gap_stop":8,"stop":87,"gap_target":2,"target":1}; partials 23, same-dayfinalexits 24. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 23.48
drawdown 32.1
win rate 49.77
sample 221
CAGR pct 4.31
mean trade pct 0.12
avg win pct 1.9
avg loss pct 1.64
halfKelly plugin 0.03
CI lower pct -0.09
CI upper pct 0.33
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 neighbor3_15_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 3-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.41598039756013533,0.1716584000385664]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"stop":118,"gap_stop":15,"time":120,"target":7,"gap_target":1}; partials 34, same-dayfinalexits 34. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -34.5
drawdown 44.79
win rate 42.53
sample 261
CAGR pct -7.2
mean trade pct -0.13
avg win pct 2.28
avg loss pct 1.92
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.42
CI upper pct 0.17
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 neighbor3_15_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 3-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.2820792593275213,0.31155701557779053]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"stop":94,"time":108,"target":5,"gap_stop":13,"gap_target":4}; partials 26, same-dayfinalexits 32. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -5.04
drawdown 38.24
win rate 43.75
sample 224
CAGR pct -1.03
mean trade pct 0
avg win pct 2
avg loss pct 1.55
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.28
CI upper pct 0.31
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 neighbor3_5_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 3-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.2562198984201958,0.33990779442520025]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"stop":114,"gap_stop":14,"time":125,"target":7,"gap_target":1}; partials 36, same-dayfinalexits 32. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 2.28
drawdown 29.39
win rate 45.98
sample 261
CAGR pct 0.4
mean trade pct 0.04
avg win pct 2.3
avg loss pct 1.88
halfKelly plugin 0.01
CI lower pct -0.26
CI upper pct 0.34
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 neighbor3_5_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 3-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.062302955218307435,0.5202556609315512]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_stop":14,"time":117,"stop":84,"target":5,"gap_target":4}; partials 30, same-dayfinalexits 28. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 53.19
drawdown 23.01
win rate 47.77
sample 224
CAGR pct 8.91
mean trade pct 0.22
avg win pct 2.05
avg loss pct 1.46
halfKelly plugin 0.05
CI lower pct -0.06
CI upper pct 0.52
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 time5_15_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. Time-only weeklyexit control. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.42498062146571663,0.2751204592455909]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":255}; partials 0, same-dayfinalexits 0. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -25.76
drawdown 48.52
win rate 52.55
sample 255
CAGR pct -5.12
mean trade pct -0.07
avg win pct 2.06
avg loss pct 2.43
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.42
CI upper pct 0.28
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 time5_15_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. Time-only weeklyexit control. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.4623022590666639,0.14163729597749822]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":220}; partials 0, same-dayfinalexits 0. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -35.39
drawdown 55.13
win rate 49.55
sample 220
CAGR pct -8.37
mean trade pct -0.16
avg win pct 1.73
avg loss pct 2.02
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.46
CI upper pct 0.14
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 time5_5_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. Time-only weeklyexit control. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.2173690604475051,0.48858693110590634]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":255}; partials 0, same-dayfinalexits 0. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 23.64
drawdown 29.76
win rate 56.86
sample 255
CAGR pct 3.82
mean trade pct 0.13
avg win pct 2.1
avg loss pct 2.47
halfKelly plugin 0.03
CI lower pct -0.22
CI upper pct 0.49
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 time5_5_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. Time-only weeklyexit control. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.26470964170669264,0.3262461573418879]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"time":220}; partials 0, same-dayfinalexits 0. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 0.32
drawdown 36.76
win rate 54.55
sample 220
CAGR pct 0.06
mean trade pct 0.04
avg win pct 1.77
avg loss pct 2.04
halfKelly plugin 0.01
CI lower pct -0.26
CI upper pct 0.33
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 primary5_15_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.31652818404002264,0.2633172689313565]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_target":1,"stop":106,"time":123,"gap_stop":17,"target":8}; partials 35, same-dayfinalexits 30. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -14.05
drawdown 39.2
win rate 44.31
sample 255
CAGR pct -2.64
mean trade pct -0.03
avg win pct 2.3
avg loss pct 1.88
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.32
CI upper pct 0.26
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 primary5_15_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage15bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.45947011023146633,0.0412389443528169]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"stop":102,"time":101,"gap_stop":11,"target":6}; partials 22, same-dayfinalexits 32. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -40.64
drawdown 52.99
win rate 40.45
sample 220
CAGR pct -9.91
mean trade pct -0.21
avg win pct 1.91
avg loss pct 1.65
halfKelly plugin 0
CI lower pct -0.46
CI upper pct 0.04
slippage bp side 15
REV9110400 primary5_5_test costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2021-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2026-09-10 04:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.14919233063956544,0.4504968275114483]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_target":2,"stop":103,"time":128,"gap_stop":15,"target":7}; partials 36, same-dayfinalexits 27. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return 34.96
drawdown 25.95
win rate 46.67
sample 255
CAGR pct 5.43
mean trade pct 0.15
avg win pct 2.38
avg loss pct 1.8
halfKelly plugin 0.03
CI lower pct -0.15
CI upper pct 0.45
slippage bp side 5
REV9110400 primary5_5_train costed weekly reversal
Backtests reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 04:09
Frozen note2174. Premises:1 Nine sector ETFs, SIP all-adjusted dailybars; 2016-01-04 05:00:00+00:00 through 2020-12-31 05:00:00+00:00. First session eachweek buys prior 5-session worstreturn sector ifnegative, priorclose signal/nextopen fill, onecash-onlyfractionalsleeve. ATR20stop1R,target3R,+2Rquarter andBEfollowingday; gapopen, conservativebarriers, weeklytimeexit. 2 Fees1bp plus slippage5bp eachside; fourphases/day vectorbt longonly cashsharing reconciled everydaily equity; nohidden leverage. 3 MeantradeCI95 [-0.21038356390757,0.27862159953439963]%, monthcluster5000bootstrap. Reasons {"gap_stop":12,"time":114,"stop":88,"target":6}; partials 26, same-dayfinalexits 25. 4 Currentincompleteweek excluded, allobservations andsource archived, openingpartial-before-intradaystop audit didnotchange anycell. Conclusion researchonly: primary fails costrobustness; controls cannotreplaceprimary afterholdoutinspection. Adjusteddividend mechanics, actual15minmonitor fills, fractionsto whole-sharepartialexits, slippage estimates andPDTremain unvalidated. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars . ThisadaptationisnotNagel's48industrydailyshortportfolio.
More return -0.69
drawdown 29.12
win rate 46.36
sample 220
CAGR pct -0.14
mean trade pct 0.02
avg win pct 1.91
avg loss pct 1.61
halfKelly plugin 0.01
CI lower pct -0.21
CI upper pct 0.28
slippage bp side 5
QTR9110200 final decision: broad discovery retained, no live adoption
Strategies reject Quant replication XLE, XLK, XLI, AXTI, SNDK, WOLF, ASML, HSBC, SWKS, QRVO, BTC/USD 2026-09-11 02:18
StartstateQuant187.22cash/account850.99, zeroopen/pending verifiedagain02:18; goalrepeatablepositive netreturns; bindingconstraint independentlyvalidatedfullruleandcurrententrytiming. Premises:1 BroadUS13176rosterattempt/12128usable;2351longmomentumranksarchived;20overseaspanel/25cryptopairs withnamedcoveragegaps.2 OriginalAQRmomentum replicatedasexplicitlydifferentmonthlysector3Radapter;8costedcells reconciled. Frozen252stress train-7.73207%N48,holdout70.31862%N190/DD21.85773%,meanCI[-.04849,2.13027]%. Positive189neighborcannotreplaceprimaryafterseeingreturns.3 No midmonthentryunderrule; whole-share62.41USDsleevescannotbuytopsectors,15minBE/gapsunvalidated.4 Issuerleaders showgenuineoperatingstrengthbutWOLFsharecontinuity,ASMLcashconversionandSWKSclearance gaps defeatheadlineentry.5 All23historyeligiblecryptonegative12-1,majorsnobreakout. Conclusion zeroopen/close/cancel/adjustorders, cashchosenforlackofvalidatedcurrentasymmetricpayoff. Validinferenceunderfrozenpolicy; soundnesslimitedbycurrentrostersurvivorship,vendoractions,short2016–18training/globalcalendarandFX,empiricalbootstrapanddailyexitproxy. Strongestcounterargument positiveholdoutcouldpay; nextprospectivewhole-share/15minimplementation isappropriate, retuningovertheinspectedholdoutisnot. HalfKellylive0; fundinggap349.01doesnotsettarget. LedgerN3alloperatorliquidationsrealized-1.04605cannotcalibratehorizon. Monitors234resolved/24804UTC/247Sep11noteexpiry,229AVAVpaperand185CPIpreserved. Collector203testedENDwith2of4accessgaps,remoteunverified;196lastverified01:45notassumed02:15success;85/15retained. Lessons730–732. NoFUNDline: noseparateoperationoutsideQuantmandate. Sources https://www.aqr.com/-/media/AQR/Documents/Journal-Articles/JPM-Fact-Fiction-and-Momentum-Investing.pdf ; https://www.nasdaqtrader.com/dynamic/SymDir/nasdaqlisted.txt ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; issueroriginals2425/2440. Researchabout18min, protectedfinalphasebegan15min, reportwithin20min/43planned/45hard; nobudgetoverrun.
More fund cash 187.22
equity 850.99
orders 0
live halfKelly 0
US screened 12128
US ranked 2351
foreign panel 20
crypto panel 25
train stress pct -7.73
holdout stress pct 70.32
holdout trades 190
holdout DD pct 21.86
QTR9110200 CLI zero-bar result is missing data, not a flat backtest
Strategies reject Quant replication XLB, XLE, XLF, XLI, XLK, XLP, XLU, XLV, XLY 2026-09-11 02:17
Premises:1 Ran node /app/agent/dist/backtest.js --symbols XLB,XLE,XLF,XLI,XLK,XLP,XLU,XLV,XLY --strategy xs-momentum --lookback252 --top3 --rebalance21 --days2500 (actualshellargumentsspace-separated correctly). CLIreturnedbars0/trades[]/return0, not evidencezeroeconomicreturn.2 Inspected /app/agent/dist/backtest/bars.js: stockfeedhardcodedIEX, firstpageonly(no pagination), noexplicitend/adjustment; code'sxsportfolioalso differsskipmonthandourfull exitrule.3 IndependentownscriptusespaginatedSIP/allwithhistoricalcutoffandexplicitfees/slippage, vectorbtlongonly, threeeventphases/daytoavoidlosingentrydayexits, all8cellsequity/tradecountsreconciled. Data2016startdespite2009requestretainedinreportedtraining. ConclusionrejectCLIresultasvalidation; usecostedcustom2403–10, noCLIreturnsborrowed. Do notquietlysubstitutefeedorrelabel252dayno-skipasAQRrule. Sources localCLI/barssource and https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; research/cli.json/test_sector.py SHA cb7f6a725110104643a5365188842047459dd903676d41cc28f9a5072e81ae79.
More CLI bars 0
CLI trades 0
custom reconciled cells 8
actual data first year 2016
requested first year 2009
live orders 0
QTR9110200 empirical sector paths and fund sizing
Simulations reject Quant replication XLE, XLK, XLI 2026-09-11 02:17
Premises:1 Sample frozen252daystressholdoutdailyportfolio, threefractionalsleeves,3000normalizedcapital.2 Seed9110200,10000paths,resampleoverlapping21dayblocks,12blocks=252sessions; preserveswithinblockdependence butmissesnovelregimes,longmemoryandfuturegaps.3 On187.22fund21sessionP5/median/P95PnL=-8.5383/1.0334/11.9949USD,lossprob0.4298,zeroempiricalgain>=349.01; annualreturnP5/50/95=-10.6848/7.1039/29.3271%,drawdownP50/95=9.4809/17.6986%. Notforecast andzerocountisnotimpossibility. Primarytrainingnegative keepshalfKelly0; temptingholdout6.14%riskplugin wouldbecapped byaccount3%normalrisk25.5297USDand187.22funddeployment/212.7475positionceiling, butnotused. A totalfundgap loss187.22wouldbe22%account, so fundcapaloneisnotgapriskbudget. Strongestcounterargument fatpositive tailsnotcapturedcanpay; doesnotjustify changingtargettomeet349.01fundinggap. Rate7.1887%CAGR over7.67yearsholdoutvs70.3186%total, not70%monthly. Sources frozen2406; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; research/inference.py/json.
More paths 10000
block days 21
fund USD 187.22
21day P5 USD -8.54
21day median USD 1.03
21day P95 USD 11.99
loss probability 0.43
gain349 probability sample 0
annual median pct 7.1
annual P95 DD pct 17.7
normal account risk USD 25.53
live allocation 0
QTR9110200 holdout exposure and trade-record calibration
Statistical inconclusive Quant replication XLE, XLK, XLI, SPY, SNOW, DELL, GTLB 2026-09-11 02:17
Premises:1 Frozen252daystress holdout190trades,38.4211%wins,averagewin8.2380%/loss3.4970%,mean1.01171%,monthclusterCI[-.04849,2.13027]%; training48mean-.51159% andhalfKelly0.2 Holdout1933dailyreturns OLS vsalignedSPY beta0.41960102253097215,correlation0.6300643543775979,dailyintercept0.000012204135180099584; annualsimpleintercept0.3075442065385095% isdescriptive, noHACsignificance/causalalpha claim. Timestampstrings normalizedtoUTC beforejoin; invalidzeroSPYearlierdiscarded.3 Recent60day XLE/XLKcorr-.253247,XLK/XLI.542399; correlationcanchange undergapstress.4 OwnledgerN3win33.33%,mean-.860974%,avgwin7.93994/avgloss5.26143%,realized-$1.04605. Alloperatorliquidations, no stopped/targetedtrade orarrivalquote; cannotestimateplannedhorizonedges,stopprobabilityorexecutionslippagefromthatrecord. Conclusion livehalfKelly0fromprimarytraining; holdoutplugin6.1405%risk isnotlicensedconfidence orvenuesizing. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; query_trades fundquant Sep1102UTC; research/inference.json; analyses2403–10.
More holdout sample 190
holdout mean pct 1.01
holdout CI lower -0.05
holdout CI upper 2.13
SPY beta 0.42
SPY correlation 0.63
annual alpha simple pct 0.31
trade sample 3
ledger win rate 33.33
ledger realized USD -1.05
live halfKelly 0