QTR9090400 institutional calendar mechanism: consequences and counterarguments
Consequences reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:12
Chain1: institutions with dated cash liabilities may sell securities before settlement deadlines; then liquidity providers absorb that supply; then prices may recover when the pressure ends. Cash recipients benefit from timely payment, while liquidity providers can benefit only if the recovery exceeds inventory risk and trading costs. The original institutional evidence supports a mechanism, not a guarantee for current ETFs. Chain2: shorter settlement can shift the required sale date; then anticipatory traders may shift inventory purchases; then the old calendar window may weaken, persist, or move. The post2024 negative estimate is descriptive and cannot establish that settlement caused it. Chain3: calendar exposure can earn ordinary equity returns; then stops truncate some profitable paths and introduce extra exit sensitivity; then the actual managed rule can lose despite a profitable parent. Here open-entry unmanaged+24.17% becomes managed-10.36% in the same frozen holdout. Strongest counterargument: the open variant still gains5.18% at stress costs and future effects might concentrate in another independently documented window. Its confidence interval spans zero, so this is a research lead, not an order. Reframed conclusion: reject this managed implementation without claiming all calendar effects are false. Fixed costs consume runway, but expected losses do not finance it. Facts are measured returns and source-described mechanisms; future consequences remain hypotheses. Sources https://www.aalto.fi/sites/g/files/flghsv161/files/2021-03/dashforcashpaper_final_complete.pdf ; https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2024-62 ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More unmanaged holdout pct 24.17
managed holdout pct -10.36
unmanaged stress pct 5.18
managed stress pct -24.07
allocation 0
QTR9090400 calendar, range and portfolio feasibility gates
Technical reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:12
The calendar signal is inactive on September 9. Fixed entry is the last session of a month; a late entry cannot borrow the historical rule's outcomes. September 8 completed adjusted closes are SPY765.96, IWM294.67, EFA107.76, EEM68.83 USD. Their trailing20-session mean daily high-low ranges are4.46606,2.445025,.65062,.67089 USD. SPY and IWM whole shares exceed the212.7475 USD account position cap. EFA and EEM are affordable individually, but the four equally funded research sleeves cannot be reproduced in whole lots with245.69USD; affordability is not evidence for selecting only those two. The managed rule combines the calendar with lagged range-based exits; adding daily-delayed trailing after+1ADR still loses9.7196% baseline and23.5284% stress. Fixed managed exits:139 stop touches,34 adverse open gaps,106 targets including46 favorable gaps capped at target,53 time exits. Two bars touch both stop and target; stop-first convention applied. Daily marks and touch fills are preliminary and do not reproduce15-minute checks or extended-session quotes. Nominal risk cap8.5099USD does not bound gaps. No technical trigger and no positive validated payoff jointly support allocation0. Sources https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; observations17276–17280 and17348; note1344.
More position cap USD 212.75
nominal loss cap USD 8.51
quant cash USD 245.69
SPY close 765.96
IWM close 294.67
EFA close 107.76
EEM close 68.83
adverse stop gaps 34
ambiguous bars 2
trailing holdout pct -9.72
allocation 0
QTR9090400 correlated monthly Monte Carlo and zero Kelly allocation
Simulations reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:11
Baselinefixedmanagedholdout p=.4307228916, averagewin1.45484631%, averageloss1.32374598%; quarterKelly=max(0,.25*(p-(1-p)*loss/win))=0. Stressalso0. Numpyseed90904 samples83monthlyfour-assetvectors jointly,20000paths x12months, compoundingindependentinitiallyequalsleeves; withinmonthassetreturncorrelations .52669–.80692. Hypothetical245.69USDfullresearchportfolio annualprofit2.5/50/97.5percentiles[-24.87985,-3.89916,19.27193]USD; lossfrequency63.785%. Zeroof20000pathsreach349.01USD, afiniteempiricalresultnotimpossibility. Onecalendarwindowmeanprofit-.311885USD,2.5/50/97.5percentiles[-4.68193,-1.08460,6.39000]. Fixedcostsexcluded, noforecastcashinterest; futuretailsmaybeworse, stationarityandindependentmonths assumed. Thisfractional4sleeveexperimentdoesnotmeetcurrentwhole-lotconstraintsandisnotallocation. AtmostonewindowremainsinSeptemberafterSep9; cannotturnmonthlyfrequencyinto dailyincome. Stopgapexits34of332; worsttrade-6.75243%showsnominalstopnotguaranteedriskbound. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; finish_stats.py and frozenstudy.py.
More paths 20000
months per path 12
quarter Kelly 0
annual median USD -3.9
annual p2.5 USD -24.88
annual p97.5 USD 19.27
loss probability 0.64
one window expected USD -0.31
stop gap exits 34
worst trade pct -6.75
proposed notional 0
QTR9090400 no robust modern calendar premium after correlated-sample correction
Statistical reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:11
Premise1 fourETFreturns are correlated: holdoutdailySPY/IWM .8659 andSPY/EFA .8543;332eventtradesrepresent83calendarwindows. Dailycross-ETFaverage regressedonconstant pluslast/first3daydummy, NeweyWest5lagSE. Holdout1760sessions,336TOMdays mean .0582627% versusother .0501137%; premium .0081490%,HACt .11495,95%CI[-.130797,.147095]%. ThuspositiveabsoluteTOMreturns neednotbe calendaralpha. Premise2 costschangefixedmanagedmeanfrom-.126943% to-.326489%, andmonthbootstrap95%stressCI[-.610288,-.037112]%; rejectspositiveedge. Premise3 postMay28 2024 dailycalendarpremium-.090084%,CI[-.321507,.141340]% across401sessions, notproofT+1causeddecay. ManagedpostT1 76trades/19windows mean-.156972%,p42.105%. Premise4 2026calendarpremium+.237545% hasCI[-.167466,.642555]%; recentstrengthdoesnotoverrideholdout. Trainingalsoinsignificant. Theopenvariant+24.17% baseline/+5.18%stressisstrongestcounterexamplebutitsstressmeanCI[-.415888,.558456]% spanszeroandlacksexits. Conclusionuncertainrawcalendarpremium, rejectedmanagededge, nosymbolcherry-pick. Dailycalendarregressionincludesboundarydays whereasportfolioexcludesboundary-spanningtrades. Fullnumericresults observations17282–17286 andcompleteexperiments. Sources https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars ; https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2024-62 .
More holdout sessions 1760
TOM sessions 336
calendar premium pct 0.01
HAC t 0.11
premium CI low -0.13
premium CI high 0.15
independent time clusters 83
managed mean pct -0.13
stress mean pct -0.33
postT1 managed N 76
allocation 0
QTR9090400 holdout benchmark midmonth 16bp per side
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:11
2019–25 fixedfourETF universe. Vectorbt explicitlongonly four250USDinitial independentcashsleeves, fees1bp plus slippage15bp per side. Calendarcontrol enters8thsessionopen exits11thsessionclose eachmonth,4sessionexposure.84months336trades; turn-of-month test83completewindows omitsyearboundarycrossingtrades. Notexactpairedcausalcontrol, no optimization. No stop/target so notdeployable. Fractionals,cash0yield, fixedoperatingcostsexcluded. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars?symbols=SPY,IWM,EFA,EEM&timeframe=1Day&feed=sip&adjustment=all ; finish_stats.py.
More return -24.22
drawdown 33.11
sample 336
win rate 49.11
mean trade pct -0.29
cost bps per side 16
QTR9090400 holdout benchmark midmonth 6bp per side
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:11
2019–25 fixedfourETF universe. Vectorbt explicitlongonly four250USDinitial independentcashsleeves, fees1bp plus slippage5bp per side. Calendarcontrol enters8thsessionopen exits11thsessionclose eachmonth,4sessionexposure.84months336trades; turn-of-month test83completewindows omitsyearboundarycrossingtrades. Notexactpairedcausalcontrol, no optimization. No stop/target so notdeployable. Fractionals,cash0yield, fixedoperatingcostsexcluded. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars?symbols=SPY,IWM,EFA,EEM&timeframe=1Day&feed=sip&adjustment=all ; finish_stats.py.
More return -10.35
drawdown 28.69
sample 336
win rate 54.46
mean trade pct -0.09
cost bps per side 6
QTR9090400 holdout benchmark buyhold 16bp per side
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:11
2019–25 fixedfourETF universe. Vectorbt explicitlongonly four250USDinitial independentcashsleeves, fees1bp plus slippage15bp per side. Firstsessionopen tolastsessionclose. Fourhighlycorrelated long-durationtrades, notfourindependentedgeestimates; benchmarkhasmoremarketrisk andnovenueexits. Fractionals,cash0yield, fixedoperatingcostsexcluded. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars?symbols=SPY,IWM,EFA,EEM&timeframe=1Day&feed=sip&adjustment=all ; finish_stats.py.
More return 120.07
drawdown 35.36
sample 4
win rate 100
mean trade pct 120.07
cost bps per side 16
QTR9090400 holdout benchmark buyhold 6bp per side
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:11
2019–25 fixedfourETF universe. Vectorbt explicitlongonly four250USDinitial independentcashsleeves, fees1bp plus slippage5bp per side. Firstsessionopen tolastsessionclose. Fourhighlycorrelated long-durationtrades, notfourindependentedgeestimates; benchmarkhasmoremarketrisk andnovenueexits. Fractionals,cash0yield, fixedoperatingcostsexcluded. Source https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars?symbols=SPY,IWM,EFA,EEM&timeframe=1Day&feed=sip&adjustment=all ; finish_stats.py.
More return 120.51
drawdown 35.36
sample 4
win rate 100
mean trade pct 120.51
cost bps per side 6
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_1.25_2_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1.25ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 0.94
drawdown 2.56
win rate 43.75
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.13
average win pct 2.09
average loss pct 1.39
CI low pct -0.73
CI high pct 1.22
quarter Kelly 0.02
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_1.25_2_6
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1.25ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 2.57
drawdown 1.92
win rate 50
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.33
average win pct 2.03
average loss pct 1.36
CI low pct -0.53
CI high pct 1.42
quarter Kelly 0.04
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_1_2_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return -0.43
drawdown 3.32
win rate 37.5
sample 32
mean trade pct -0.04
average win pct 2.17
average loss pct 1.37
CI low pct -1
CI high pct 1.14
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_1_2_6
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 1.17
drawdown 2.83
win rate 40.63
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.16
average win pct 2.21
average loss pct 1.24
CI low pct -0.8
CI high pct 1.34
quarter Kelly 0.02
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_0.75_2_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop0.75ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 0.26
drawdown 2.7
win rate 34.38
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.04
average win pct 2.33
average loss pct 1.15
CI low pct -0.81
CI high pct 1.13
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_0.75_2_6
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop0.75ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 1.88
drawdown 2.21
win rate 37.5
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.24
average win pct 2.34
average loss pct 1.01
CI low pct -0.61
CI high pct 1.34
quarter Kelly 0.03
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_0.75_1.5_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop0.75ADR/target1.5ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return -0.97
drawdown 2.91
win rate 34.38
sample 32
mean trade pct -0.11
average win pct 1.87
average loss pct 1.15
CI low pct -0.83
CI high pct 0.76
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_sensitivity_0.75_1.5_6
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop0.75ADR/target1.5ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 0.63
drawdown 2.31
win rate 37.5
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.09
average win pct 1.92
average loss pct 1.01
CI low pct -0.63
CI high pct 0.96
quarter Kelly 0.01
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_trail_1_1.5_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule trail: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1ADR/target1.5ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; trail1ADRactivatedafter+1ADR and updatednextday, NOT15minuteimplementation. Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return -1.43
drawdown 3.41
win rate 34.38
sample 32
mean trade pct -0.17
average win pct 1.87
average loss pct 1.24
CI low pct -0.95
CI high pct 0.76
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_trail_1_1.5_6
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule trail: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1ADR/target1.5ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; trail1ADRactivatedafter+1ADR and updatednextday, NOT15minuteimplementation. Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 0.16
drawdown 2.93
win rate 43.75
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.03
average win pct 1.65
average loss pct 1.23
CI low pct -0.75
CI high pct 0.96
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_managed_1_1.5_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule managed: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1ADR/target1.5ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return -1.66
drawdown 3.41
win rate 37.5
sample 32
mean trade pct -0.2
average win pct 1.75
average loss pct 1.37
CI low pct -1.01
CI high pct 0.76
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_managed_1_1.5_6
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule managed: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1ADR/target1.5ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return -0.07
drawdown 2.93
win rate 40.63
sample 32
mean trade pct 0
average win pct 1.81
average loss pct 1.24
CI low pct -0.81
CI high pct 0.96
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_open_0_0_16
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule open: last-session open to nextmonththirdclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 3.28
drawdown 5.5
win rate 53.13
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.42
average win pct 1.86
average loss pct 1.21
CI low pct -0.75
CI high pct 1.59
quarter Kelly 0.06
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_open_0_0_6
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule open: last-session open to nextmonththirdclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 4.94
drawdown 5.31
win rate 62.5
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.62
average win pct 1.77
average loss pct 1.3
CI low pct -0.55
CI high pct 1.79
quarter Kelly 0.09
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_parent_0_0_16
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule parent: penultimate-session close to nextmonththirdclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 4.52
drawdown 6.51
win rate 56.25
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.58
average win pct 2.34
average loss pct 1.67
CI low pct -1
CI high pct 2.15
quarter Kelly 0.06
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 extension_parent_0_0_6
Backtests inconclusive Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. extension test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage5bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule parent: penultimate-session close to nextmonththirdclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return 6.2
drawdown 6.23
win rate 59.38
sample 32
mean trade pct 0.79
average win pct 2.41
average loss pct 1.59
CI low pct -0.8
CI high pct 2.36
quarter Kelly 0.08
cost bps side 6
calendar windows 8
QTR9090400 holdout_sensitivity_1.25_2_16
Backtests reject Quant replication SPY, IWM, EFA, EEM 2026-09-09 04:09
Frozen specification note1344. Provider SIP adjustment=all2016–Sep8 2026, every2685NYSEsession present for eachETF; no2010–15 data supplied. holdout test, onlyentries AND exits within partition; holdout2019–25 has83 completecalendarwindows/332correlated ETFtrades, boundaryspanningtradesexcluded. Fourindependent initiallyequal250USD cashsleeves, no leverage, no periodiccross-sleeverebalance, idlecash0. Vectorbt from_orders explicitlongonly, fee1bp plus slippage15bp/side; rawcash-return reconcileswithVBT tradeP&L accounting for entryfee denominator. Rule sensitivity: last-session open; lagged20sessionmean(high-low) stop1.25ADR/target2ADR; otherwisethirdsessionclose. Managed dailyOHLC stop-first ambiguity, adversegap fillsopen, targetgapcappedtarget; Dailybar touchfills preliminary; no claimed15minexecution, nor whole-lot/currentcap replication. Bootstrap10000 completecalendarwindowmeans acrossfourETFs, not332independenttrades; CI and per-symbol statistics saved observationmatchingtitle. Verdict rejects liveadoption when uncertainty/cost/executiongatesfail; positivepointestimatealone isnotadoption. Source https://business.purdue.edu/faculty/mcconnell/publications/Equity-Returns-at-the-Turn-of-the-Month.pdf ; https://runway.adityaperswal.workers.dev/data/stock-bars .
More return -14.57
drawdown 19.42
win rate 43.98
sample 332
mean trade pct -0.19
average win pct 1.61
average loss pct 1.59
CI low pct -0.52
CI high pct 0.15
quarter Kelly 0
cost bps side 16
calendar windows 83